Web WonderAll things web related plus a few surprises

Antique Yixing Zisha Teapot Market – Analysis

Personally, I always rely on my own judgment in buying art. I have made my own art, in a number of mediums; I bought my first ceramic art, back in 1970. I studied art, I have had friends who are artists, and I have been dealing in various forms of art since that first purchase (which was sold only with the sale of my country inn, in 2000). I did not spend a lot of money on those teapots, and I liked them. As it turned out they were fakes of very famous teapot art, so I was not off the mark in my old teapot appreciation.

Over the years, I have learned a lot about Chinese Yixing zisha teapots, old and new. As it turns out, for old teapots, many people started making copies (fakes) of old teapots and aging them (bathtub full of dirt; then, dry). Actually, I am familiar with the basic techniques from my business making furniture and folk art reproductions and my other business of buying and selling the real thing. To make aged painted furniture, for example, we used old nails and milk paint and buried it in manure for a week. Brass can be aged by putting it in a place with fumes from ammonia. Then, we just used old glass with bubbles in it to make cabinets that looked antique. The point is that that is nothing new. People have been making both fakes and reproductions of many forms of art for many years.

In teapots, the situation is much worse, on a number of fronts. First of all, the way in which teapots have been signed by an artist, off and on, over the past several hundred years, is with that artist’s or factory’s stamps, which have the Chinese characters of their names, sometimes, somewhat stylized. The stamp is usually on the bottom of the pot, which appears to have begun with the Gong Chun teapot. Later, marks were also included on the underside of the lid, and underneath the handle, although there are variations. We have also heard of a tradition that the direction of the stamp should be along the axis of handle and spout facing front, but, then, we have seen that particular rule also violated. Before the late 1800′s, it was also common for carved lettering to appear on teapot surfaces. Some specific details also apply to certain periods. In the 1940′s and 1950′s, wooden seals were used with Chinese characters but no actual names. In the 1960′s, a cooperative was formed, and all teapots were stamped only with Zhong Guo Yi Xing.

However, it was also common, during that period, for artists to put their own seals under the lid. During the cultural revolution of 1966 to 1976, artists were not permitted to put their seals on teapots but were assigned a number. The point is that it is easy to make a copy of the stamp from the original stamp impressions on original teapots, which can also be done with carved lettering. Before the 1960′s, impressions of the original seals were taken with red wax, which made a slightly smaller seal that the original. These days it is done by computer. In comparison, it is much more difficult, for example, to forge the written signature of an artist, Chinese or Western, although that also is not impossible, and many forged paintings of past artists have turned up over the years. In fact, the use of a black light can also sometimes help to reveal fakes, in paintings.

The next thing is materials. As I mentioned, when we made reproductions of furniture and folk art, we used nails that were made by a company the same way for 200 years. We used milk paint that was also made the same way for several hundred years. Then, we could also get hardware that was antique, and we could even get wooden boards that were several hundred years old. We, then, finished pieces with our own homemade finishes, using the same materials that had been used for making finishes for hundreds of years. In teapots, there is old clay available because, for example, teapot artist families have been buying clay from Yixing mines for many, many years and have passed some of it down through the generations. However, one of the real differences for older clay and older teapots is that the particle size of the rock powder making up the clay was about twice as large, in the mid-Qing Dynasty, about three times as large in the early Qing Dynasty, and about five times as large, in the Ming period. Thus, at least you should expect teapots to appear rougher, the further back you go, although that same sort of roughness can be seen even with more recent clays.

The other thing about teapots is that, although actual original teapots by a famous artist have a definite appearance, that is only an approximate circumstance. First of all, since each is made by hand, there might be slight variations from one to the next, although minor. Secondly, there is nothing equivalent to, for example, the “signature” brushstrokes that one might observe in an oil painting by a famous artist, for teapot art. For example, we recently saw a copy of a teapot by a contemporary artist with whom we are familiar. There was nothing at all wrong with it, technically, but it happened that the signature was put at an improper place, according to our knowledge from owning an original. In fact, we would have bought the copy, but it was also priced at a higher price than we have to pay for originals. More importantly, part of the actual learning process for making Yixing teapots is to copy those of your mentor and of other famous artists, so copying masterworks is even built into the instructional system of the art. We even have an artist friend who specializes in making copies, down to the last detail, of famous teapots, although he does not sell them as anything more than reproductions. We see other great copies of famous and not so famous contemporary and past teapots, all around. From what we hear from our dealer sources and from our sources, in Yixing, itself, over ninety percent of the famous-name or antique teapots that have been sold over the last few decades, as originals, are actually fakes, especially those that were sold to foreign buyers, during that time. We have seen similar numbers quoted in other articles about antique teapots.

Yixing teapots have been sold to the rest of the world for several hundred years, having been shipped with tea by European tea companies to European countries. Even as early as the late 1600′s, both Dutch and English potters made fake Yixing teapots because the ones being imported from China were all the rage. Others were also shipped to Asian countries, for example, gongju teapots to Thailand. So, it is not impossible for old Yixing teapots to be found outside China, in addition to those that were not shipped outside but were later purchased by foreign buyers from mainland sellers. However, with those shipped in earlier centuries, you have to figure that not many were shipped, in the first place, and few survived since most people did not consider them to be that special and ceramics are easily breakable. Even the Sunbeam Tiger automobile from the 1960′s that I owned in the 1990′s only had about one third of the original production left by that time, just twenty-some years later. In addition, as you go back in time, there were very few teapot artists; it is not the thousands that we have, today, someof whom mass produce teapots. As a result, Yixing teapots bought by foreign buyers from China over the last several decades are considered by most of us, in China, today, to be fairly suspect.

We recently were, in fact, approached by a foreign seller who said he wanted to sell his collection of about one hundred antique teapots beck to China. Over the last several years, many foreign sellers have sold their teapots through local auctions, knowing that there was a price bubble in some sectors of the teapot market. This seller, who approached us, through the internet, sent us some pictures of rather common looking teapots, which he told us to show to any dealer and they would immediately know what they were. Now, we are not experts in antique teapots, but we know some, in dealers, and in Yixing multi-generational teapot art families. We also see thousands of teapots, both old and new, at the many teapot dealers, shops, studios and galleries that we pass through. We see fakes that are sold as fakes and fakes that we know are fakes from experience. Indeed, we had seen similar teapots, somewhere in our wanderings, but we sent the pictures along to our experts, too. What we got was ridicule for wasting their time.

In the end, making copies has been part of the art, itself, and copies and fakes have been around for centuries. The first wave of copies, in the twentieth century, was actually commissioned by several respected companies in Yixing and Shanghai, in the early 1900′s. They had the best artists of the day make copies of famous teapots from earlier periods, originally intended as reproductions. Eventually, those showed up in circulation offered as authentic, in later years. There was another wave of making fakes of all sorts of teapots beginning in the 1980′s, prompted by increased foreign demand due to the normalization of cross-strait relations with Taiwan, and it continues into today. Indeed, China is, now, famous for its copies of everything, and we see all sorts of things copied, from cigarettes to IPods and more.

Of course, as with any other art, provenance is a key in purchasing old and new teapots. For newer teapots, artists actually make up hand-written certification that it is their teapot, and that can be passed on from one owner to the next. It is much like getting the publisher’s certification for a 20th century lithograph by a famous artist. That is at one extreme. However, we even know a contemporary teapot artist who told us that he met a Taiwanese man at an exhibition, in New York City, who bought what was supposed to have been a teapot made by that artist, and he had paid around $20,000 for the teapot. He even had a written certification, but when the artist examined it, he said that the certification and the teapot were not genuine. He could tell because, although the forged hand-written signature was very good, the artist is actually left-handed, and the certificate was signed by a right-handed person. Our friends, in Yixing, who are both teapot artists and historical teapot scholars, tell us that often they see foreign collectors, who truly believe that they have authentic teapots because the good fakes are the only ones that they have ever seen or owned. I have even seen others comment on that in articles and blogs.

A few months back, my assistant was careless with a contemporary teapot that we have in the gallery and broke it. To make up for it, she went to a dealer, on Shamian Island, in Guangzhou, near the White Swan Hotel, the most expensive foreigner hotel, in town, who she thought might tell her where to get it repaired. Instead, he sold her an exact replica of our teapot that he said was made by the artist’s grandfather. It had a stamp on the bottom that was the same family name, and it was made to look old. Fortunately she paid only around $40 for it because after I got back from a short business trip, we called the artist, and she told us that her grandfather never even made teapots. So, there are even fakes, on the market, by people who never existed, which is something you could only know, if you have the right connections. It even seems that some of those foreign buyers do not even know the proper history of the teapots that they have bought. For example, just the other day we saw an advertisement on a Taiwan E-bay-like website to sell a gongju teapot, which teapots were actually made in the late Qing Dynasty, but on the website it said that it was from the Ming Dynasty, only a few centuries off the mark. Even the experts sometimes have trouble either detecting copies or in dating teapots. It is said that some experts are still arguing over the authenticity of the original Gong Chun teapot housed in the Museum, in Beijing. Of course, the Gong Chun teapot has been copied over and over, though the centuries, and even some of those copies can be valuable. In fact, we have a nice copy, and we see copies with various variations, everywhere, in the teapot markets.

At the other, provenance usually consists of the chain of ownership of the item. In that regard, sometimes a certification from a reputable art dealer is enough. On the other hand, I once bought a 19th century European painting by a known artist, from a reputable dealer with whom I had had many past dealing, and he had gotten it from a restorer, who gave his guarantee that it was authentic. In the end, I discovered that the artist’s name, just like one of our current artists, Xin Ming Xuan’s name, was misspelled in some major references about art 19th century artists, and the incorrect spelling was that, which was used to sign the painting I owned. Apparently, the restorer had “restored?” the signature, too. In the end, the dealer did take it back, but I saw it some years later, offered, again, by another dealer as an original.

As we said in another recent blog, we like to take the guess work out of art, at least, to the extent that that can be done. To that end, in teapots, we have contacts in many of the older artists whose work is being sold, in both originals and copies. We also have contacts in several teapot art dynasty families, so we can completely authenticate some teapots back through over a hundred years. We also have friends who have done a lot of dealing and research in older teapots, who know all of the tricks and pitfalls in the fakes markets.

As I said, I am not a superme expert in antique Yixing teapots, but I have a lot of on the ground experience in general teapots and the teapot markets, in China. I have been an expert, in a number of fields, including quantum field theory, functional analysis, securities and econometric analysis, merger arbitrage, securities law, fine inn keeping, art, making “antiques”, investment psychology, life in Modern China. I have also learned that one can find and use experts to help fill in knowledge and experience, and I can learn from them while I am using their services. In the end, currently, we do little buying in older teapots unless they are simply nice older teapots at reasonable prices, whether or not we know the name.

We like good art, and, while we would never say that a price on a work of art was too high just because of the dollar amount on the price tag. I have spent millions of dollars, personally, on art over the years. However, as an investor, I understand reasonable versus bubble prices, no matter if it is oil prices, the price of the Chinese stock market, prices for folk art from the 18th century, or real estate prices in Guangzhou (the real arbitrage, there, is to rent: we pay Y3,000 per month rent, whereas the owner has a mortgage of over Y8,000 per month = losing proposition for the owner). Teapot prices are already too high for works of some contemporary artists, never mind those for works of famous dead artists. A true indicator of that fact is the number of foreign sellers over the last few years who have put their old teapots up for auction, in mainland China. In other Chinese art, everyone is looking to go the other direction and sell outside the mainland, be it in Hong Kong, London, or New York.

You can see some Yixing teapots and links to some other antique teapot sites on our site and blog. You can easily find a number of references about zisha clay, Yixing teapots, famous teapot artists over the last several centuries, and teapot art by searching the web.

© 2009 Craig Mattoli, CEO, Red Hill Capital Corporation, owner, Leona Craig Art: all worldwide rights reserved.
http://www.leonacraig.com
http://blog.leonacraig.com

About the Author

The Marketing Century – Graham Hales – Branding

Like Mike $6.96 When a 13-year-old orphan (rapper Lil’ Bow Wow) finds a pair of mystical sneakers, he suddenly acquires the skills of a certain basketball legend. With his newfound ability, he fulfills his dream of playing in the NBA. But when the nefarious headmaster of the orphanage where Bow Wow lives cooks up a plot to steal the shoes, the diminutive dunker must choose between his career and his true wish of …

Michael Jordan to the Max (Large Format) $9.98 The greatest basketball player of all time gets an appropriate clip reel in this 45-minute documentary, which was originally released in the IMAX format. While you can’t simulate IMAX’s 80-foot-high screen in your living room, you can still get the thrills and awe-inspiring footage of this tribute to one man’s talent and endurance. Much of the original footage was shot during the 1997 NBA Finals b…

Benita Valente, Soprano – Great Singers of the 20th Century, Vol. 1 $12.65 All products are BRAND NEW and factory sealed. Fast shipping and 100% Satisfaction Guaranteed….

Dancetime Vol.2: 20th Century [VHS] $39.95 …

Burn Notice: Season Two $14.90 Burn Notice settles into a satisfying groove in its second season. The cast is cool and confident, the writers have mastered the mix of stand-alone stories and the season-long hook, and the blend of retro-70s flavor with 21st century self-awareness is delicious. Michael Westen (Jeffrey Donovan) still hasn.t figured out who .burned. him–i.e., got him blacklisted as a covert agent and left him trap…

The 5th Quarter $7.18 Based on a true story, this inspirational drama concerns Jon Abbate (Ryan Merriman), a talented linebacker at Wake Forest University whose world is shattered when his younger brother Luke is killed in a car accident. As his parents, Steven (Aidan Quinn) and Maryanne (Andie MacDowell), deal with their grief, Jon dedicates the 2006 football season to Luke–helping to lead his squad to the Orange Bow…

The Ringer $6.23 Johnny Knoxville (Jackass, A Dirty Shame) stars as a man who pretends to be mentally challenged so he can fix the Special Olympics. This morally dubious premise (the movie goes to great lengths to be sure you understand how appalling it is) is not as inflammatory as it could be–The Ringer is careful not to mock its mentally challenged characters. This is sometimes a source of strength, as some of…

Heel Tastic Intensive Heel Therapy, 2 ounces $8.64 Watch dry, cracked heels disappear! As seen on TV. Look at the amazing results! With natural neem and karanja oils. Easy to use. Fast results. No mess. Great scent. Discover the remarkable healing power of ancient essential oils in HeelTastic, the miracle balm that repairs rough, dry skin quickly and easily. Created by a renowned chemist, desperate for relief from her own cracked, dry feet, HeelTa…

The Business of the 21st Century $5.00 Employee or entrepreneur? Which would you rather be in the 21st century? Robert Kiyosaki explains how you can take advantage of these economic times to build wealth and create a happier life through network marketing! Multimillionaire investor, business owner, educator, speaker, and the best-selling author of the Rich Dad Poor Dad series is sold network marketing and wants to share his insight…

4+1 Big Discount Alpha Impact Human Pheromones soap Attract Sex & Women Get 1 Free $49.95 No, it is not marketing hype-this is our world in the 21st century and now we have the ability to quickly make new friends, seduce lovers, and even be more successful using the scientifically proven effects of pheromones! Pheromones are found naturally in all living things and have been proven to create a sexual response when inhaled by the opposite sex. Sadly, we wash away pheromones with soap …

Marketing: Marketing in the 21st Century $120.99 The updated 11th edition of Evans and Berman’s Marketing: Marketing in the 21st Century text continues its savvy transformation into a state-of-the-art multimedia package. The subtitle signifies the focus on marketing concepts essential for the future success of any organization or person, presented in a technologically advanced pedagogical format. As with any human endeavor that begins with the seed of an idea, puts down roots and is nourished by warmth and food, marketing needs a solid foundation and nurturing to grow and flourish. The new 11th edition explains this necessity and how to achieve this goal. The print version has all the elements that you expect from Evans and Berman: comprehensive topical coverage, colorful design, cases, career material, etc.

Marketing in the 21st Century Integrated Marketing Communication, Volume 4 by Keillor, Bruce David Edition , 0 $51.99 Marketing in the 21st Century Integrated Marketing Communication, Volume 4. Keillor, Bruce David

Marketing $539 Marketing

Marketing: Marketing in the 21st Century (with Online eBook Printed Access Card) $145.49 The updated 11th edition of Evans and Berman’s Marketing: Marketing in the 21st Century text continues its savvy transformation into a state-of-the-art multimedia package. The subtitle signifies the focus on marketing concepts essential for the future success of any organization or person, presented in a technologically advanced pedagogical format. As with any human endeavor that begins with the seed of an idea, puts down roots and is nourished by warmth and food, marketing needs a solid foundation and nurturing to grow and flourish. The new 11th edition explains this necessity and how to achieve this goal. The print version has all the elements that you expect from Evans and Berman: comprehensive topical coverage, colorful design, cases, career material, etc.

Pharmaceutical Marketing in the 21st Century $194.03 This book is in Good Used condition

Social Marketing in the 21st Century $40.8 This book is in New – Excellent condition

Marketing in the 21st Century $325 This book is in New – Excellent condition

The Marketing Century by Kourdi, Jeremy J. Edition ILL, 1 $15.49 Written to celebrate the Institute’s centenary, The Marketing Century explains: how the key elements of marketing have developed; how the various aspects of marketing contribute to performance; what it is that great marketers do; and how the discipline of marketing may develop in the future.While The Marketing Century describes the years since 1911 it also describes the 21st Century: a time when the ability to understand and connect with customers is more rewarding, complex and valuable than ever. It explains:The three forces shaping the past, present and future of marketing: globalization, technology and ethicsHow people behave and connect – and how businesses can benefit from these insightsThe need to manage for the long-term as well as the short-termMarketing’s impact on business strategy and leadershipThe last 100 years have seen a rapid rise in the impact of marketing. It is an activity which has grown in scope and significance, with more people than ever before now engaged in the exciting, fast-changing world of marketing.The development of the Chartered Institute of Marketing closely reflects the growth and progress of business in general and marketing in particular. Just as marketing has developed as an activity that is highly valued, varied and vital in its contribution to business success, so the Institute’s work has expanded as an indispensable source of insight, guidance and practical support.The Marketing Century provides expert analysis of some of the most significant developments in marketing of the last 100 years – and the next 100.Each chapter looks at the past, present and future of a different area of marketing, with chapters covering:Strategic Marketing (Martha Rogers and Don Peppers)Customer Relationship Management (Merlin Stone)Segmentation (Malcolm McDonald)Innovation (John Saunders and Veronica Wong)Public Relations (Paul Mylrea)Branding (Graham Hales)Advertising (Jonathan Gabay)Digital Marketing (Philip Sheldrake)Sales and Business Development (Beth Rogers)Sustainability (John Grant)Internal Marketing (Keith Glanfield)Social Marketing (Paul White and Veronica Sharp)Each chapter explains:How the subject has developedWhat is currently ‘best practice’How this aspect of marketing connects with other topicsThe influences and trends shaping the future

Marketing: Marketing in the 21st Century, by Evans, 8th Edition $4.35 This book is in Used condition

Marketing: Marketing in the 21st Century, by Evans, 10th Edition $101.95 This book is in New – Excellent condition

Marketing: Marketing in the 21st Century, by Evans, 9th Edition $23.71 This book is in Used condition

Instructor’s Edition Marketing 10e: Marketing in teh 21st Century by Evans, Joel R. Berman, Barry Edition , 10 $91.95 The new 10th edition of Evans and Berman?s Marketing 10e text continues its savvy transformation into a state-of-the-art multimedia package. The subtitle, Marketing in the 21st Century, signifies the focus on marketing concepts essential for the future success of any organization or person, presented in a technologically advanced pedagogical format. The print version has all the elements that you expect from Evans and Berman: comprehensive topical coverage, colorful design, cases, career material, etc.

Marketing in the 21st Century Company and Customer Relations, Volume 3 by Keillor, Bruce David Edition , 0 $13.49 Marketing in the 21st Century Company and Customer Relations, Volume 3. Keillor, Bruce David

Principles of Marketing Engineering by Lilien, Gary L.; Rangaswamy, Arvind; De Bruyn, Arnaud Edition , 0 $23.99 Marketing engineering blends the scientific rigor of marketing analytics with the craft of traditional marketing to create the 21st Century tools for marketing decision making

Principles of Marketing Engineering by Lilen, Gary L Rangaswamy, Arvind De Bruyn, Arnaud Edition , 0 $33.99 Marketing engineering blends the scientific rigor of marketing analytics with the craft of traditional marketing to create the 21st Century tools for marketing decision making

Social Marketing in the 21st Century by Andreasen, Alan R. Edition ILL, 0 $22.99 The goal of this cutting edge book is to reposition social marketing so that foundations, government agencies, and various nonprofits will approach social change in a way that reaches both upstream and downstream individuals in society. Author Alan R. Andreasen outlines potential roles, restates fundamental principles, and then suggests how social marketing might be applied to a sample of nontraditional challenges.  

Marketing Management by Kotler, Philip; Brady, Mairead; Goodman, Malcolm; Hansen, Torben; Keller, Kevin Edition ILL, 1 $74.99 The first European edition of Marketing Managementreinvigorates this classic text by exploring the challenges 21st century marketing managers face.

Marketing Research: State-of-the-Art Perspectives $42.99 This is an authoritative, twenty-first-century guide to marketing research practices. This book is the voice of marketing research experts at the turn of the millenium. It collects insights from the best-known practitioners and academics in the world, including authors from the U.S., Canada, England, Scotland, and Australia. Each chapter is written by a specialist in the topic area. So the book provides state-of-the-art coverage of a spectrum of marketing research topics including the process from data to knowledge, the current practice of marketing research, and the variety of specialized forms of research. It also offers perspectives on issues of particular importance to the Information Age, such as Internet research and computer-aided qualitative data analysis.

International Marketing by Terpstra, Vern Sarathy, Ravi Sarathy, Ravi Edition , 8 $65.99 Drawing on the extensive and unparalleled international marketing experience of its authors, International Marketing takes a comprehensive look at the environment, problems, and practices of today’s international marketing arena. This text gives students a real-world taste of this dynamic field, preparing them for entry into the marketing workplace of the 21st century.

Marketing Health Care into the Twenty-First Century $34.95 This book is in New – Excellent condition

Marketing Trends for Organic Food in the 21st Century $238.06 This book is in Used condition